Prices and stock checked daily from the world's finest stores 5 Star Weddings
Manolo Blahnik Maysale 70 Buckled Suede Pumps, styled view
Fashion /

Spend or Save: Four Designer Heels and the Pairs That Cost Less

Four designer heels from Tom Ford, Saint Laurent and Manolo Blahnik, each set beside a lower-priced pair in the same shape, from £90.

By Taiwo Adedayo

Every piece here has been chosen by our editors. We may earn a commission on some products.

Four shapes account for most of the heels women wear: the black pointed pump, the slingback, the buckled court and the strappy gold sandal. For each we have set a designer pair beside a lower-priced one in the same shape, from £90 to £979, all in stock now.

Tom Ford 110mm Eva Pointed-toe Leather Pumps in Black
Tom Ford 110mm Eva Pointed-toe Leather Pumps in Black
The black pump

Tom Ford or Calvin Klein

Spend: Tom Ford’s Eva is black leather with a pointed toe on a 110mm stiletto. £870.

Save: Calvin Klein’s black pointed-toe pump is also a slip-on stiletto, for £142. Reiss’s Marlene, £90, adds cut-out twist detailing around the vamp and a cushioned leather insole.

TOM FORD 110mm Eva Pointed-toe Leather Pumps in Black, view 3TOM FORD 110mm Eva Pointed-toe Leather Pumps in Black, view 4
Saint Laurent Babylone Breteuil Slingback Pumps in Smooth Leather in Brown
Saint Laurent Babylone Breteuil Slingback Pumps in Smooth Leather in Brown
The slingback

Saint Laurent or Reiss

Spend: Saint Laurent’s Babylone Breteuil is brown lambskin with an elongated toe, a low stiletto heel and the Cassandre at the front. £979.

Save: Reiss’s Carla, in chocolate, is smooth leather with an elongated pointed toe, a slender slingback strap and a low kitten heel. £170.

Saint Laurent Babylone Breteuil Slingback Pumps in Smooth Leather in Brown, view 4Saint Laurent Babylone Breteuil Slingback Pumps in Smooth Leather in Brown, view 5
Manolo Blahnik Maysale 70 Buckled Suede Pumps
Manolo Blahnik Maysale 70 Buckled Suede Pumps
The buckle

Manolo Blahnik or Reiss

Spend: Manolo Blahnik’s Maysale has been made since 1991. This one is dark brown suede with the buckle at the pointed toe, on a 70mm heel. £795.

Save: Reiss’s Beatrice is chocolate suede with two buckled straps, a slingback, a pointed toe and a higher stiletto. £98.

Close-up detail of the Manolo Blahnik Maysale 70 Buckled Suede PumpsBack view of the Manolo Blahnik Maysale 70 Buckled Suede Pumps
Manolo Blahnik 90mm Callasli Sandals in Gold
Manolo Blahnik 90mm Callasli Sandals in Gold
The gold sandal

Manolo Blahnik, Stuart Weitzman or Reiss

Spend: Manolo Blahnik’s Callasli is gold-tone, open at the toe, on a 90mm heel. £775.

Between: Stuart Weitzman’s has two gold-tone straps on a stiletto, £313. Save: Reiss’s Alex is metallic leather with twisted cord straps and a tapered heel, £98.

Manolo Blahnik 90mm Callasli Sandals in Gold, view 3Manolo Blahnik 90mm Callasli Sandals in Gold, view 4

Where the money goes

The difference between a £90 heel and a £900 one is mostly in what you cannot see: the last the shoe is shaped on, the leather sole, the way the heel is set and how well it keeps its line after a season. Spend on the shape you wear every week, such as a black pump; save on the pair you wear twice a year. Walk on a hard floor before you decide, and buy in the afternoon, when feet are at their largest.

Watch: save or splurge

Film: “Save or Splurge? $55 Red Heels vs. $1,690 Designer” by Wedeh | Personal Style, on YouTube. The shoes in the film are not from our shop.

Every pair in this story

See all our Heels, checked for price and stock every morning.

Shop the Edit Heels 10 pieces in this story · from £90 Shop now →
The Journal

Keep Reading

The newsletter

The Edit, weekly

What's new, what's worth it and what's about to sell out. One email a week, no noise.